Vorlage:1948 Rezensionen Der Tod des Sokrates
Aus Romano-Guardini-Handbuch
Version vom 9. April 2024, 12:09 Uhr von Helmut Zenz (Diskussion | Beiträge)
- [Englisch] Ready, and almost ready (Kurz-Rezension zu: Guardini, The Death of Socrates), in: America, 79, 1948, 24. April, S. 60 [neu aufgenommen] – [Rezension] - https://books.google.de/books?id=SBwQAAAAIAAJ; zu Romano Guardini:
- S. 60: „Romano Guardini we all know as one of the most attractive of writers on the liturgy. Well, we have just published a book by him, called, of all things, THE DEATH OF SOCRATES ($ 3.00). In it he gives us four of the dialogues of Plato with a running commentary, in the course of which he covers every aspect of the Christian idea of death. Between Guardini and Socrates, it manages to be an extraordinarily cheerful book.“
- Eb: Rezension zu: Guardini, Der Tod des Sokrates, in: „Berg-Skopus.“ Blatt der jüdischen Studentenschaft der britischen Zone, 1948, 6, S. 8 [Mercker 3112] - [Rezension] - [noch nicht online]
- [Französisch] Rezension zu: Guardini, Der Tod des Sokrates, in: Documents. Paris/Offenburg, 3, 1948, 7/8, S. 630f. [Gerner 339] - [Rezension] - https://www.dokumente-documents.info/fileadmin/uploads/tx_ewsdokumente/doc_1948_07_08_ausgabe_01.pdf
- Das beste Buch. Umfrage - Urteil - Unsere Leser sollen prüfen. Staatsintendant Alois Johannes Lippl: Romano Guardini: „Der Tod des Sokrates“. Eine Interpretation der platonischen Schriften. (Keine Erläuterung nötig), in: Echo der Woche, München, 2, 1948, 71 (17. Dezember 1948), S. 9 [Gerner 262] - [Artikel] - [noch nicht online]
- Hans Gerstinger: Rezension zu: Guardini, Der Tod des Sokrates, in: Anzeiger für die Altertumswissenschaft, 3, 1950, S. 109-111 [neu aufgenommen] – [Rezension] - https://books.google.de/books?id=2h_gAAAAMAAJ
- P. H. (Paul Hühnerfeld): Abendländisches Denken (Rezension zu: Guardini, Der Tod des Sokrates), in: Die Zeit, Hamburg, 1948, 16. September [Mercker 3113, bei Mercker ohne Autorenangabe] - [Rezension] - https://www.zeit.de/1948/38/abendlaendisches-denken
- Hans Kudszus: Der große Prozess (Rezension zu: Guardini, Der Tod des Sokrates), in: Der Tagesspiegel, Berlin, 1948, 25. April [Mercker 3119] - [Rezension] - [noch nicht online]
- [Englisch] Helmut Kuhn: Rezension zu: Guardini, Der Tod des Sokrates, in: German books. A selective critical bibliography of publications in German, Chicago, 1, 1948, S. 71f [neu aufgenommen] - [Rezension] - https://books.google.de/books?id=_v9FAQAAIAAJ
- [Englisch] C.E.S.: The Godly Pagan (Rezension zu: Guardini, The death of Socrate), in: The Living Church, 117, 1948, 26. September, S. 21 [neu aufgenommen] – [Rezension] - https://books.google.de/books?id=RFfkAAAAMAAJ&pg=RA12-PA21:
- S. 21: „The method of this book is the conventional and fruitful one of setting out the text of a classic and interspersing it with a a running commentary and exposition. The text in this case consists of four dialogues of Plato: the Euthyphro, Apology, Crito, and Phaedo. Guardini believes, and demonstrates pretty cogently, that the wisdom of Socrates (referred to hereunder as Socrates-Plato) is in its essence religious wisdom rather than essentially rational wisdom. He interprets Socrates-Plato as an intuitive thinker. The great Platonic arguments for the immortality of the soul and the reality of the eternal "Ideas" are logically developed in the dialogues, but they all ultimately take their start from what the Christian would call the insights of faith. This is the reason for their unending religious significance and appeal. There is a profound „natural piety“ in Socrates-Plato. Henry Mencken calls this quality of his, in an impish but memorable phrase, „labored Peck-sniffery“! Certainly it must appear as something like that to any reader who has no religious instinct. The commentary of this work is sound and thorough, but it must be read with extreme carefulness if you are to follow Guardini´s reasoning. It is not altogether free from certain stiffness and turgidity of style, though the fact that it is a translation from German probably accounts fort hat; and certainly it is more lucid than most translations of German works on abstract subjects. If you will read this book with the necessary care you will have a rich reward. After all, „the word of the master“ is here in the text, and if you find Guardini a bit hard to follow here and there you can always turn to Plato for clarification! If you put yourself into your reading you will probably lay the book down with a greater love for, and understanding of, Socrates: that gay and godly pagan whom to know is a joy and a cordial, and who through the ages continues to play so noble a part in the Preparation of the Gospel.“
- [Englisch] James A. Magner: Rezension zu: Guardini, The death of Scorates, in: The American Ecclesiastical Review, 119, 1948, S. 316 f. [neu aufgenommen] – [Rezenzsion] - https://books.google.de/books?id=APrNAAAAMAAJ&pg=PA316
- Rezension zu: Guardini, Der Tod des Sokrates, in: Die Neue Zeit, München, 4, 1948, 43 (30. Mai 1948), S. 4 [Gerner 339] - [Rezension] - [noch nicht online]
- Rezension zu: Guardini, Der Tod des Sokrates, in: Neues Abendland, Augsburg, 3, 1948, 9, S. 287 [Gerner 339] - [Rezension] - [noch nicht online]
- [Englisch] Edwin A. Quain: Rezension zu: Guardini, Der Tod des Sokrates, engl., in: America, New York, 79, 1948, 6. November, S. 135 [Mercker 3127, bei Mercker versehentlich „National catholic weekly“ statt „America“] - [Rezension] - https://books.google.de/books?id=SBwQAAAAIAAJ;
- [Englisch] Hans A. Reinhold: Rezension zu: Guardini, Der Tod des Sokrates, engl., in: Commonweal, New York, 48, 1948, 13. August, S. 432 [Mercker 3128] - [Rezension] - https://books.google.de/books?id=JGEQAAAAIAAJ;
- [Englisch] Dorothy Tarrant: Rezension zu: Guardini, Der Tod des Sokrates, engl., in: The Hibbert Journal, London, 46, 1947/48, April 1948, S. 281f. [Mercker 3129] - [Rezension] - https://books.google.de/books?id=REoMAQAAIAAJ;
- [Englisch] Platonic Thought (Rezension zu: Guardini, Der Tod des Sokrates, engl.), in: The Times. Literary supplement, 1948, 22. Mai, S. 293 [Mercker 3130] - [Rezension] - [noch nicht on-line]
- [Englisch] H. L. Varley: Rezension zu: Guardini, Der Tod des Sokrates, engl., in: Springfield Republicain, Springfield (Mass.), 1948, 4. Juli, S. 10 A [Mercker 3131] - [Rezension] - [noch nicht online]
- [Englisch] Joachim Wach: Rezension zu: Guardini, Der Tod des Sokrates, in: German books. A selective critical bibliography of publications in German, Chicago, 1, 1948, S. 48 [neu aufgenommen] - [Rezension] - https://books.google.de/books?id=_v9FAQAAIAAJ